로그인




연락처 :
bolle1917@gmail.com

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/may/08/puerto-ricos-debt-crisis-greece


Puerto Rico's debt crisis is a wake-up call. It could be crushed like Greece

Puerto Rico’s future is not in the hands of its people, but in the hands of a group of non-elected technocrats, that as such are not accountable to Puerto Ricans

protest puerto rico
‘Will now the US help or crush Puerto Rico?’ Photograph: Alvin Baez/Reuters

P

uerto Rico’s government recently declared that the country will seek bankruptcy under Title III of Promesa, a federal law enacted by the US Congress to deal with Puerto Rico’s debt crisis. The decision triggers the beginning of a debt restructuring process, the largest ever registered in the municipal bond market of the US.

It was a sensible move. The country does not have the means to pay its debt. It needs to restore the sustainability of its debt position as a pre-condition for any plan for economic recovery, and the only way for that is through a restructuring process.

Not declaring bankruptcy would have exposed Puerto Rico to massive litigation that would have not boded well for the island. At least 22 lawsuits had already been filed by a myriad of the island’s creditors. Vulture funds, which specialize in suing countries in disgrace to get full payment on debts that they buy in times of distress at large discounts, could have made a killing at the expense of Puerto Ricans and good faith creditors.

Promesa provides a legal framework with elements that are similar to a bankruptcy law, and as such it can certainly help the island and its creditors to achieve an effective and orderly restructuring; but to be sure, Promesa is not a guarantee of success.

It is a framework that didn’t come alone, but with the imposition by Congress of a bipartisan financial oversight and management board in charge of making the fiscal policy decisions for the island. 

For a large part, Puerto Rico’s future is not in the hands of its people, but in the hands of a group of non-elected technocrats, that as such are not accountable to Puerto Ricans. If that sounds like what happens in colonies, that’s precisely because Puerto Rico is a US colony.

The first signs of the board’s behavior had been worrisome. In January, it demanded a set of draconian austerity measures, including large cuts to pensions, education and health spending, that would have led to catastrophic outcomes – including drops in economic activity not too different from the ones that Venezuela has been recently experiencing. In March, the board finally approved a slightly more moderate 10-year fiscal plan that is projected to lead to another lost decade for Puerto Rico.

Absent a substantial debt write-off, the fiscal plan will not only aggravate the recession, it will also worsen the sustainability of the country’s debt position – thus risking the country entering into a third consecutive lost decade after 2026.

It is now the time for Puerto Rico’s government and the board to outline a debt restructuring plan. And there is much uncertainty about the role the board will play. Will it respect its mission of creating “the necessary foundation for economic growth and to restore opportunity to the people of Puerto Rico”? Or will it try to squeeze as much as possible from the island to maximize the payment to the creditors in the short run, even if that means seriously aggravating its troubles?

Signs are not more encouraging when it comes to the White House’s stance. A few days ago, Donald Trump showed how much he cares about the lives of Puerto Ricans when he tweeted: “Democrats are trying to bail out insurance companies from disastrous #ObamaCare, and Puerto Rico with your tax dollars. Sad!”

Ultimately this crisis may be a wakeup call for Puerto Ricans, as the territorial experiment is reaching a critical point. The glossed-over territorial status created by the US in the mid-20th century – Puerto Rico’s Estado Libre Asociado, or Commonwealth – has been seriously undermined by the territory’s fiscal crisis. It is clear that being in a political middle ground is the worst of all worlds for Puerto Rico. It is a ground where there is serious risk of becoming another Greece.

And it’s also a wakeup call for the US. Deepening the Puerto Rican crisis would lead to higher migration to the mainland, and US taxpayers would have to pay for the costs that this would entail.

All stakeholders are now being forced to show their cards. The board’s actions will soon determine the degree of similarities between Puerto Rico and Greece. An important one is already in order: Greece lost its de facto sovereignty; thus, its authorities had no capacity to make decisions on behalf of the electorate when it came to resolving the country’s debt crisis. 

The Troika got the power and it crushed Greece, depriving a generation of opportunities in their own land. Will the US now help or crush Puerto Rico? Puerto Ricans will soon know. What happens next will not only affect the economy, but it might also bring political changes – in one direction or the other – that for better or worse will reshape the future of the country.

Martin Guzman is a research associate at Columbia University Business School, professor of economics at University of Buenos Aires, and non-resident senior fellow at the Center for a New Economy in Puerto Rico.

?

List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
96 [베네수엘라] A Criminal Affair: United States Imposes War on the Venezuelan People 볼셰비키 2019.05.18 217
95 [이탈리아/예멘/사우디] Italian dock workers refuse to load Saudi arms ship over Yemen war 볼셰비키 2019.05.21 454
94 [이스라엘/ISIS/시리아] Former Israeli Defense Minister Confirms Israeli Collaboration with ISIS in Syria 볼셰비키 2019.05.27 123
93 [쿠바/트로츠키] “In Cuba we needed Trotsky to understand what happened in the Soviet Union” 볼셰비키 2019.05.28 218
92 [아프리카/수단] Military Police Open Fire on Protesters in Sudan's Capital - Correspondent 볼셰비키 2019.06.02 60
91 [이스라엘/팔레스타인] Mass grave uncovered containing dozens of Palestinians killed in 1948 war that founded Israel 볼셰비키 2019.06.06 185
90 [이란/미국/ICL] Down With U.S. War Moves Against Iran! 볼셰비키 2019.06.10 58
89 [수단/미국] Sudan violence prompts Trump admin. to send senior envoy to meet military leaders 볼셰비키 2019.06.14 88
88 [홍콩/중국] Police crackdown against Hong Kong protesters opposing extradition bill 볼셰비키 2019.06.14 92
87 [알제리/IG] Algeria: For Workers Revolution Against the Military Regime! 볼셰비키 2019.06.16 3542
86 [독일/스탈린주의] Stalin’s persecution of German communists 볼셰비키 2019.06.19 13943
85 [베네수엘라/미국] The Failed Venezuelan Coup and the Decline of US Hegemony 볼셰비키 2019.07.01 68
84 [온두라스/미국] Honduras at Ten Years After the Coup: a Critical Assessment 볼셰비키 2019.07.01 92
83 [수단] What next after Sudan's Million Man March? 볼셰비키 2019.07.02 126
82 [독일/미국] 'Germany is Not a Banana Republic!': Ex-Chancellor Slams Trump's Treatment of Europe Like 'Vassals' 볼셰비키 2019.07.07 70
Board Pagination Prev 1 ... 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 ... 45 Next
/ 45