로그인




연락처 :
bolle1917@gmail.com

조회 수 922 추천 수 0 댓글 0
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄

Questions on the ICL’s position on Syria: reading 13 December 2019

 

“These warring sides have received support from foreign imperialist or regional powers. For example, Russia and Iran have backed Assad, while the Pentagon and CIA have armed and financed various Sunni forces fighting the regime.”Workers Vanguard No. 1167, 13 December 2019, On the Syrian Civil War

 

The ICL raises the support of imperialist or regional powers to the both sides who took part in the so-called “civil war” as a basis for neutrality.

So,

1) Can “regional powers” be equated with imperialism?

2) Is Russian and Iranian intervention imperialistic?

3) Is “Syrian civil war” a competition or proxy war between imperialist rivals?

Marxists should not only present the phenomena as they are, but also explain the real foundation, or nature. But the ICL does not explain why the conflict, which it describes as a “civil war or communal war”, and why the imperialist U.S. and regional powers Russia and Iran are involved.

4) What is the background of imperialism and local powers’ involvement in this conflict, which is nothing but a “civil war”?

 

*     *     *

“Though it has intervened in Syria, the U.S. has not decisively entered the civil war with its own armed forces to remove Assad. If Washington were to launch a direct attack or invasion of the country, Marxists would take a military side with Assad’s forces against imperialist assault while maintaining our political opposition to his rule.”ibid

 

During the past eight years of war, behind the “civil or communal war”, the United States has not only provided financial, military, and mass media support to the anti-Assad rebels, but has also staged various military operations, staying within Syrian territory. Nevertheless, the ICL says, “If Washington was to run a direct attack or an investment of the country. Marxists would take a military side with Assad’s forces against imperialist assault while maintaining our political opposition to his rule.”

So. 5) what does the “direct attack or involvement ” mean to the ICL? How do you define it?

 

Feb 29, 2020

Bolshevik EA

?

  1. No Image 29Oct
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/10/29 by 볼셰비키
    Views 948 

    [Collapse of the IBT] The Bankruptcy and Collapse of the IBT

  2. No Image 30Oct
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/10/30 by 볼셰비키
    Views 802 

    [Collapse of the IBT] Iran, nationalism and imperialism

  3. No Image 31Oct
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/10/31 by 볼셰비키
    Views 1213 

    [Collapse of the IBT] Summary of Our Thought on "Islam Revolution" in 1979 in Iran

  4. No Image 31Oct
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/10/31 by 볼셰비키
    Views 691 

    [Collapse of the IBT] On the "Farewell Comrades(resignation letter of the Riely's faction)"

  5. No Image 31Oct
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/10/31 by 볼셰비키
    Views 818 

    [Collapse of the IBT] Collection of our contributions on Egypt, Turkey and Brazil for the internal debate

  6. No Image 01Nov
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/11/01 by 볼셰비키
    Views 752 

    [Our Program] Thoughts on China

  7. No Image 01Nov
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/11/01 by 볼셰비키
    Views 994 

    [Our Program] Our Position on 17th presidential election of South Korea/2007

  8. No Image 08Nov
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/11/08 by 볼셰비키
    Views 1013 

    [Collapse of the IBT] We are defending the tradition of Lenin and Trotsky not of Seymour (2018/0811)

  9. No Image 25Nov
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/11/25 by 볼셰비키
    Views 628 

    [Our Program] The Program of the Bolshevik-Leninist

  10. No Image 07Dec
    by 볼셰비키
    2018/12/07 by 볼셰비키
    Views 515 

    [Our Program] The South Korean 18th presidential election and the IBT/2012

  11. No Image 10Jun
    by 볼셰비키
    2019/06/10 by 볼셰비키
    Views 751 

    Defend Iran against imperialist colonial aggression!

  12. Our Position on 'the Protest Against the Transmittal Act' in Hong Kong

  13. Criticism of the “Short Thought on Hong Kong Protest” of Labor and Social Science Institute

  14. No Image 20Nov
    by 볼셰비키
    2019/11/20 by 볼셰비키
    Views 487 

    Three axes of the Hong Kong situation : imperialism, bureaucracy and the working class’s revolutionary vanguard

  15. No Image 29Feb
    by 볼셰비키
    2020/02/29 by 볼셰비키
    Views 922 

    Our Questions on ICL’s position on Syria: reading 13 December 2019

  16. On imperialist media and ‘leftist’ cheerleaders

  17. No Image 18Sep
    by 볼셰비키
    2020/09/18 by 볼셰비키
    Views 1556 

    The Essence of Conflict on the Korean peninsula and the Response of the Working Class

  18. The Exchanges with Revolutionary Regroupment: Imperialism, National Liberation and Permanent Revolution

  19. The long lasting hegemony of British-US imperialism, Anglo chauvinism and the degeneration of Trotskyism

  20. No Image 20Jan
    by 볼셰비키
    2021/01/20 by 볼셰비키
    Views 1301 

    On the Belarusian Crisis: Down with the capitalist counter-revolution and the imperialist regime change!

Board Pagination Prev 1 ... 2 Next
/ 2