로그인




연락처 :
bolle1917@gmail.com

http://www.counterpunch.org/2016/09/30/can-russia-learn-from-brazils-fate/

Can Russia Learn From Brazil’s Fate? 

Photo by PSB Nacional 40 | CC BY 2.0

Photo by PSB Nacional 40 | CC BY 2.0

 

William Engdahl recently explained how Washington used the corrupt Brazilian elite, which answers to Washington, to remove the duly elected President of Brazil, Dilma Rousseff, for representing the Brazilian people rather than the interests of Washington. Unable to see through the propaganda of unproven charges, Brazilians acquiesced in the removal of their protector, thereby providing the world another example of the impotence of democracy.

Everyone should read Engdahl’s article. He reports that part of the attack on Rousseff stemmed from Brazil’s economic problems deliberately created by US credit rating agencies as part of Washington’s attack to down grade Brazilian debt, which set off an attack on the Brazilian currency, the real.

Brazil’s financial openness made Brazil an easy target to attack. One might hope that Vladimir Putin would take note of the cost of “economic openness.”  Putin 2KillingTheHost_Cover_ruleis a careful and thoughtful leader of Russia,  but he is not an economist. He has confidence in neoliberal Elvira Nabiulina, Washington’s choice to head the Russian central bank.  Nabiulina is unfamiliar with Modern Monetary Theory, and her commitment to  “economic openness” leaves the Russian economy as exposed as Brazil’s to Washington destabilization. Nabiuina believes that the assault on the ruble is due to impersonal “global market forces,” not to Washington’s financial clout.

Nabiulina, an indoctrinated and propagandized neoliberal, is essentially a servant of Washington, not that she is aware of her role as “useful idiot.” She delights in the applause she receives from the Washington Consensus for leaving the Russian economy open to Washington’s manipulation. Being a neoliberal, she does not understand that Russia’s central bank can create at zero cost the money with which to finance productive projects in Russia.  Instead, she thinks that the money entering the economy from the central bank is inflationary, but the money entering the economy from foreign sources is not.

Money is money regardless of whether it is made available by the central bank or by foreign creditors.  As long as the money, whatever its source, is used productively, the money is not inflationary.

There is a huge difference between the money created by the central bank and the money created by foreign creditors.  Money lent by foreign banks in the form or US dollars or euros must be repaid with interest in the foreign exchange in which the money was lent.  Money created by the central bank to finance public infrastructure projects does not have to be repaid at all, much less with interest and in foreign exchange earned by exports.

Funds acquired from borrowing abroad bring many risks.  The money can be pulled out, collapsing a freely traded ruble.  The interest that must be paid is a drain on Russia’s foreign currency reserves. Foreign borrowing also brings a foreign exchange risk, which rises with economic sanctions. If the ruble drops in value or is driven down with an orchestrated attack, the ruble cost of the foreign loan can rise dramatically.

None of these risks and costs are present when the central bank is the source of money. The appropriate use of the Russian central bank is to create the money with which to finance public projects and to serve as lender of last resort to private Russian companies unable to obtain funding elsewhere. This use of the central bank insulates the Russian economy from orchestrated destabilization.

It is unfortunate for Russia that Nabiulina and prime minister Dmitry Medvedev believe that Russian debt financed by hostile foreigners is preferable to money created by Russia’s own central bank.  Glazyev, alone among Putin’s advisers, understands this.  We suspect that the Atlanticist Integrationists have a target on Glazyev’s back as they hope to integrate Russia with the West regardless of the costs to Russia. These Russian “America Worshipers” are Russia’s greatest problem.

For Washington, neoliberal austerity is for “export only” to countries that Washington intends to turn into dependent financial colonies. By accommodating Washington’s goal, Nabiulina is engaging in a charade.  The dollars and euros borrowed from abroad are not the money that goes to the Russian borrowers.  The borrowed foreign exchange is held by the central bank.  Nabiulina then creates the rubles that finance the projects.  There is no point whatsoever to borrowing foreign currencies as backing for domestically created rubles.  Regardless of whether Russia borrows abroad, the central bank must create rubles with which to finance the projects.  So there is no point to the foreign borrowing.

A Russian government that cannot understand this is in deep trouble.

?

List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
84 [러시아] The Russian Revolution: then and now 볼셰비키 2017.03.08 123
83 [러시아] The Russian Navy Is on the Verge of Collapse 볼셰비키 2015.01.23 121
82 [러시아] The Russia as ‘imperialist’ thesis is wrong and a barrier to solidarity with the Ukrainian and Russian people 볼셰비키 2015.02.10 112
81 [러시아] Russian resurgence: how the Kremlin is making its presence felt across Europe 볼셰비키 2015.02.17 52
80 [러시아] Russia's "Startling" Proposal To Europe: Dump The US, Join The Eurasian Economic Union 볼셰비키-레닌주의자 2015.01.04 105
79 [러시아] Putin Warns Europe: Total War If Obama Arms Ukraine 볼셰비키 2015.02.10 89
78 [러시아] Most Russians regret the collapse of the USSR 볼셰비키 2016.12.06 10
77 [러시아] Most Russians Prefer Return of Soviet Union and Socialism: Poll 볼셰비키 2017.04.30 51
76 [러시아] Moscow doubles down on Washington 볼셰비키 2015.10.24 50
75 [러시아] More Than Half of Russians Want New Soviet State - Poll 볼셰비키 2016.06.07 29
74 [러시아] Europe Fractures: France Pivots To Putin, Cyprus Offers Moscow Military Base, Germany-US Splinter On Ukraine 볼셰비키 2015.02.10 89
» [러시아] Can Russia Learn From Brazil’s Fate? 볼셰비키 2016.10.03 7
72 [러시아/중동] Russia's Big Guns Go to War 볼셰비키 2016.10.25 31
71 [러시아/미국] Russia and Its BRICS Partners Gradually Abandoning Dollar in Mutual Trade 볼셰비키 2019.05.08 114
70 [러시아/ICL] 러시아는 제국주의 국가인가? 볼셰비키 2019.01.08 95
Board Pagination Prev 1 ... 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 Next
/ 42